Touch interfaces vs The ‘Real Deal’ - thoughts
One of the reasons I traded in my P1i for the N95 was that the interface left me unsatisfied. Even a simple action like answering a call became quite a dull task, I didn’t feel rewarded in any way by the whole experience. There’s a certain sense of satisfaction associated with pressing a button to do something - even moreso when the button itself is ’satisfying’ to press.
With the iPhone setting standards in terms of interface design and user interaction (for phones, anyway), it seems quite sad to me that we appear to be nearing an era where phone buttons probably won’t exist. Buttons obviously have major restrictions - in that they’re only made to produce an on/off effect or in some examples a pressure sensitive effect. For me, touching a flat screen - even if it launches an amazing sequence of digital trickery and movement - is a very, very dull experience. You may be interacting with the media inside the phone, but you’re interacting with it on a very non-personal level, and the screen doesn’t give you anything back in return.
So is there any scope for having a next generation phone ‘interact’ with you, like the click back of a button when it’s pressed? It’s something I’d like to put to some people, to see if it’s just me with these crazy thoughts. Maybe the next step from a fully interactive, multi touch screen is a screen that somehow makes your content ‘touchable’, like braille. Imagine if a set of buttons raised from the screen when you wanted to make a call, and fell back when you’d finished dialling.









